12 Cat Toys That Even Picky Cats Will Love

I earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Do you have a cat that is impossible to please? Does it seem like they’re never happy with any toy you buy them? I’ve got just the solution. Below you’ll find toys that even your picky cat will love. These toys will keep them happy and entertained.

Interactive Laser Toy

No cat can resist this fun and interactive laser toy. This clever toy for cats is sure to appeal to any cat’s natural hunting instinct. Your kitty will love chasing the moving pointer across your floors. Get it on Amazon.

INTERACTIVE LASER TOY

Catnip Baguette

This baguette cat toy is a perfect for any cat. Made from felt and organic catnip, this handmade toy will bring joy to any household. Get it from Mini Tiger Design.

CATNIP BAGUETTE

Cat Toy Roller

If you’re looking for a cat toy that’ll last a long time, offer your cat plenty of hours of play time, and look darn cute in your living room, this is it.

This cat toy turntable has 3 levels to keep your kitty entertained. They’ll spend hours batting the ball around on the turntable. It’s purrfect! Get it on Amazon.

CAT TOY ROLLER

Knitted Wool Stuffed Mouse

If you love handmade cat toys, you’ll love getting these cute stuffed mice for your kitty. Each mouse is hand knitted from various yarns such as cotton, wool, and acrylic. Get it from Happy Cats Farm.

KNITTED WOOL STUFFED MOUSE

Catnip Filled Cartoon Mice

Your cats will be begging to chew on and play with these catnip filled cartoon mice toys.

This toy is made of breathable fabric that allows your cats to smell the catnip easily which is sure to make them more interested in playing with it. Get it on Amazon.

CATNIP FILLED CARTOON MICE

Blueberry Pancake

Keep your little furry friend happy and entertained with an awesome blueberry pancake cat toy. This handmade toy is stuffed full of organic catnip that will give your kitty hours of play time.

Give these adorable toys as gifts or just spoil your own furry friends. Get it from Mini Tiger Design.

BLUEBERRY PANCAKE

Star Wand Toy

If you want to entertain and tire out your cat, this toy will get your cat on its feet. It has 100% organic catnip inside that they absolutely love and it’ll keep their attention for hours. Get it from Cattus Toys.

STAR WAND TOY

Extra Crispy Catnip Pizza

Who can resist a slice of pizza? Especially one that is extra crispy and full of catnip! This toy is handmade out of organic vegan materials, with organic catnip and a crunch material. Get it from Miso Handmade.

EXTRA CRISPY CATNIP PIZZA

Catnip Ice Cream

It’s everyone’s favorite dessert: ice cream! Now your cat can enjoy this yummy sweet treat too with this catnip ice cream toy. The cones are filled to the brim with catnip. Get it from Feline Fun.

CATNIP ICE CREAM

PopTart Cat Toy

PopTart lovers rejoice. Now you can enjoy your favorite breakfast item with your kitty. This toy includes USDA certified organic catnip and a bell to make it irresistible to your pet. Get it from Kufman Treasures.

POPTART CAT TOY

Rainbow Cat Charmer

This bright and colorful cat charmer is an interactive cat toy that will provide your pet with excellent aerobic exercise. Enjoy bonding with your cat with this fun toy. Get in on Amazon.

RAINBOW CAT CHARMER

Kitty Croissant

This life-sized croissant toy will be your cat’s new favorite toy. Your feline friends will love playing with this breakfast treat. Get it from Miso Handmade.

KITTY CROISSANT

Simple cat teaser wand with fringes

Playtime can be so much more fulfilling with this handy cat teaser wand with fringes. Simply lengthen or shorten the string according to your preference for even more fun.

Enticing cats of all size and personality into play time is a breeze with this exciting toy they’ll have their paws all over. Get it from Meow Loops.

SIMPLE CAT TEASER WAND WITH FRINGES

If you have a cat that is impossible to please, these cat toys are just what the doctor ordered. These fun toys are sure to keep them entertained and happy.

More Posts You May Like: